Trot Watcher All Trotskyist sects boast of their democratic credentials. But is this really true? Let us examine two case studies from two individuals within Militant who tried to register their differences. Let us look at Dennis Tourish’s experiences in Militant in 1983-5: Most people who have disagreements with the CWI leadership walk away, figuring that the … Read more
Marxists have no sense of realism. Though Marx called his opponents ‘utopian socialists’, he himself was a tremendous utopian. Where he differed was his belief that moral persuasion would not be enough to bring about socialism – it required large-scale socio-economic and political transformation. It is unclear whether such a notion is much more realistic … Read more
When I first joined in the organisation, I was not a Trotskyist. I was a libertarian socialist inspired by Nietzsche as much as Marx. Over the next several months, I would be brainwashed into ditching Nietzsche as ‘reactionary’ and embracing Trotskyism as gospel. Marx, Engels, Lenin, Trotsky, Ted Grant and Alan Woods held all the … Read more
The renowned English Marxist historian and activist, E.P. Thompson, was no fan of Trotskyism. That might be one explanation for the fact that there is hardly any mention of him on the website of the International Marxist Tendency (I am not sure about other Trotskyist sects). When I was in the cult, only Marx, Engels, … Read more
From beginning to end, my time in the organisation involved being told lie after lie after lie. These people will tell any amount of lies, no matter how preposterous, in order to advance their organisation. Cults do not have any regard for the truth. Had I known these truths, I would never have joined the … Read more
Until recently, I dismissed the idea that the IMT practiced hypnosis on me. It may have been bad, but it wasn’t that bad. Until, that is, I read Jon Atack’s book Opening Minds in which he discusses what hypnosis is. Contrary to popular belief, hypnotic states are not induced only under special circumstances. The truth … Read more
Months after leaving the International Marxist Tendency, I discovered the work of Roger Scruton – or rather, rediscovered it. Scruton, who died in January 2020, had been an old hero of mine from when I had thought of myself as a conservative. After his death, I felt a tinge of sadness, suppressed because of my … Read more
All cults have the same, underlying nature. Militant in the 1970s and 80s was a similar organisation to what the IMT and CWI are now – a hyper-controlling, authoritarian cult led by a ‘guru’ or ‘gurus’ – in the case of the former, Ted Grant and Peter Taaffe, prior to the split which saw Taaffe … Read more
It is hard to escape the similarities between Trotskyism and similar cults. One cult I have been studying a lot about is the Church of Scientology. I recently began watching Leah Remini’s brilliant documentary about Scientology on Netflix. Remini, a former Scientologist, has set to work exposing the truth about her former cult, assisted by … Read more
One of the most enduring myths of Trotskyism is that there was no positive relationship between Leninism and Stalinism. Stalinism is seen as an ‘aberration’ from Leninism. Leninism is entirely innocent of all the crimes of Stalin. This comforting falsehood is used by Trotskyists to justify their continuing commitment to the revolutionary project in the … Read more